I’ve learned that SEO is not just about getting noticed — it’s about earning trust and becoming the top choice.
Wil Reynolds, founder and CEO of Seer Interactive, really got me thinking about how artificial intelligence is changing the game for us SEOs.
In his SEO Week session, “SEO is a performance channel, GEO isn’t. How do you pivot?” he emphasized that too many of us are chasing the wrong goals and crafting content that people simply don’t buy into.
Marketing isn’t just about being seen
Reynolds challenged us to look beyond visibility to what truly drives success — belief in our brand.
“Marketing was never just to be seen or be visible,” he said. “It’s about transforming that visibility into brand belief… and ultimately, being chosen.”
He outlined a crucial journey for marketers: being seen, being believed, and then being chosen.
Even when we hit that number one ranking, the job isn’t done. As Reynolds put it, “Job’s not finished.”
Low-quality marketing is everywhere
Reynolds made me rethink some of the standard marketing tactics we use that don’t actually provide value.
He criticized methods like automated outreach, saying, “That’s not marketing.”
I found myself questioning my past work habits — was it really marketing?
The industry is producing ‘zombie content’
Reynolds shed light on our tendency to churn out templated content just to rank, equating it to “zombie content.”
Lists like “best restaurants in Minnesota” when such searches aren’t even realistic? It truly made me think about content creation differently.
Short-term tactics vs. long-term brand building
Reynolds pointed out the stark contrast between short-term wins and the sustained success of building a powerful brand.
“Some focus on winning now, others play the long game,” he explained.
He made it clear that chasing immediate results often leads to producing work nobody wants.
SEO success doesn’t translate to AI visibility
Reynolds illustrated this with an example about “ethical jeans,” showing how AI results can diverge significantly from SEO.
A brand could rank highly on Google yet fail to gain traction in AI models due to a lack of genuine credibility.
Visibility without belief doesn’t lead to outcomes
Just having visibility doesn’t guarantee anything if people don’t trust or believe in us. A reality check I needed.
This visibility is merely a stepping stone, not the end goal.
What people say matters
Reynolds encouraged us to listen actively to how people discuss brands, especially on platforms like Reddit.
Despite how brands might try to show themselves as leaders, user sentiment can reveal a drastically different picture.
The wrong metrics are being measured
Many of us fall into the trap of focusing on easy-to-track metrics instead of those that tell the real story.
Reynolds suggested that if our visibility isn’t driving results, we’re looking at the wrong data points.
Watching real users changes the picture
He emphasized the breakthroughs that come from observing actual users interact with AI tools. It’s eye-opening and transformative.
Start with your brand
Understanding exactly how our brand is perceived in AI-generated content is vital.
If we’re not ensuring our brand is accurately represented, all our marketing efforts might be in vain.
AI can shape your brand narrative
Reynolds shared a personal experience where AI misrepresented his company, prompting him to take action by publishing clear, corrective content.
There is too much content
With all this content flooding the digital space, I’ve realized the importance of stepping back and curating high-quality material instead.
Rethinking performance
Reynolds drew attention to the varying effectiveness of different traffic sources, reminding me to focus on the ones that truly convert.
A final question for marketers
He left us pondering: Are we prepared to give up a fraction of visibility for the sake of being more credible?
Inspired by this post on Search Engine Land.














